baluch pattern
Sanaullah Baloch Mir Mohammad Ali Talpur Karlos Zurutuza Selig Harrison Malik Siraj Akbar Zaffar Baloch Sanaullah Baloch: Exploitation of Mineral Wealth... Mir Mohammad Ali Talpur: Negligent dereliction of duty... Karlos Zurutuza: Inside Iran's Most Secretive... Selig Harrison: The Chinese Cozy Up... Malik Siraj Akbar: Remembering Qambar Chakar... Zaffar Baloch: Balochistan's Burden...

Bullet-Riddled Body of Ex-BSO Vice Chairman Dr. Abid Shah and Three Others Found in Panjgur, Quetta

PANJGUR/QUETTA: The bullet-riddled dead bodies of four missing Baloch persons, including that of a prominent leader of the Baloch Students Organization Dr. Abid Shah Baloch, have been recovered from Panujgur and Quetta districts, sources confirmed.

In another case, the mutilated body of a member of the Baloch Students Organization (Azad), Tariq Rahim Baloch, was also found in Quetta.

According to the details, Dr. Abid Baloch, a former vice chairman of the Baloch Students Organization (BS), Abdul Sattar Baloch, a government school teacher and Safeer Baloch, all three natives of Panjgur, had been whisked away together by the personnel of the Frontier Corps (FC) some nine months ago.

According to the initial reports, their bullet-riddled dead bodies have been found in Pangur. More details have yet to come.

A local source told The Baloch Hal that it seemed that the victims had been killed some time ago before being dumped in mountainous parts of Chitkan area.

Members of the missing persons families recognized the victims.

The family members of these missing persons had been protesting in front of press clubs in Karachi and Quetta demanding to the human rights groups to take notice of their loved ones enforced disappearance.

Tariq Karim, an activist o the BSO who had been whisked away allegedly by the activists of the intelligence agencies from Karachi, was killed and dumped in Quetta’s Bypass area.

While condemning the fresh killings, the Baloch National Front (BNF) has given the call for a complete shutter down strike and decided to block the Sindh-Balochistan Highway.


From before: PANJGUR DIARY: Dr. Abid Shah — I

By Malik Siraj Akbar

I am not kind of anti-cliché. Clichés sound good only if they are repeated at a pertinent time. One such statement that I have repeatedly cited while writing about Balochistan is by Martin Niemoller about, according to Wikipedia, the inactivity of German intellectuals following the Nazi rise to power and purging of their chosen targets. He states:

“THEY CAME FIRST for the Communists,

and I didn’t speak up because I wasn’t a Communist.

THEN THEY CAME for the trade unionists,

and I didn’t speak up because I wasn’t a trade unionist.

THEN THEY CAME for the Jews,

and I didn’t speak up because I wasn’t a Jew.


and by that time no one was left to speak up.”

The recent enforced disappearance of three citizens in Panjgur — Dr. Abid Shah, Abdul Sattar Baloch and Safeer Baloch—allegedly by the Frontier Corps (FC) gives a warning sign that the “threat” is at everybody’s doorstep. Lack of respect from the security forces for human rights and international standards to treat citizens has become the order of the day in Balochistan, Pakistan’s oil and gas rich province.

Dr. Abid Shah is the closest person I have ever known to be picked up by the security forces. While his illegal detention, massive protests in our ancestral Panjgur district in response to the gruesome episode and the sentimental hunt by his four-year old son outside the Deputy Commissioner’s Office provide me every reason to write a politically-charged write-up, I still feel like dedicating much space in this piece to my personal relations with Abid Shah and his family.

It was only when I started to proof-read this write-up when I realized how rambling it was. I have always wanted to write more about my childhood days in Panjgur. Abid’s arrest provided me some time to think back about the past. It was very painful for me to read the other day in the newspapers that his four-year son participated in a protest intended to seek his release. The young boy shouted outside the Deputy Commissioner’s Office: “ Daddy, where are you? Please come soon. I can’t live without you,” he shouted loudly in an effort to ensure his message snubbed the security officers and directly touched the ears of the missing father. Sigh!

I started to know Abid’s family when I was in class two at Government Model High School Chitkan (Panjgur) in 1991. At such an early age, I remember doctors’ writing pads were my first crush. I was too lucky to get one from this new guy in our class. The new boy was a cousin of Waheed Badal, one of the very first people along with his brother Rauf whom I still remember as my first class fellows from school. (It was so tragic to hear about Waheed’s death a few years ago in a road accident. He was too young to die!)

In our school, people would normally identify the new-comers not with their names but with the profession of their fathers. It was always the monitor of the class who would gleefully and flauntingly inform us that DSP’s (Deputy Superintendent of Police) or Session judge’s son was joining our class. They were treated like VIP students. They were normally non-locals who would speak Urdu with us. Every one of us would want to befriend them. No school in Panjgur would get so many “VIP students” as ours because Model School was (is) located in the district headquarters. The school was too close to the official residences of government officers, making it easier for their kids to attend.

The latest announcement in our class was about the arrival of a doctor’s son. It was the first time I would ever meet a doctor’s son! Dr. Rahim Baksh of Sordo, our family doctor, was the first physician I had ever known in my life but never got a chance to meet his children who were presumably much older than me.

The new boy in our class was called Sajjo. His real name was Sajjad, who was, I subsequently learned, Abid’s younger brother. Much to my surprise, this “VIP student” spoke Balochi and belonged to Panjgur even though his grandfather, Syed Mobin Shah, was an Afghan. They had lived and adapted to Panjgurian society for many years. They were not the only such family. For those who do not know much about Panjgur, it is interesting to mention that a current provincial minister and a senator from Panjgur are both not Balochs originally. For instance, the father of Mir Asadullah Baloch, who is currently the provincial minister for agriculture and an MPA from Panjgur, was originally a Pashtun Sadozai and the father of Sabir Baloch, a senator from the PPP, was a Punjabi.

Panjgur is not the only case. Another such classic example is that of Syed Ehsan Shah, the provincial minister and an MPA from Kech whose father, a Punjabi, came to the district as a businessman and adapted the local setup.

Getting back to Sajjad’s story, he gifted me a blue writing pad, marking the inception of our friendship! The Model High School was then divided into two parts: The middle and high sections were accommodated in the current building located near popular Haji Aziz’ Petrol Pump (Other’s call it Obaid’s Pump) while we, the students of primary section, were placed in the same building that now accommodates the Helper’s Public School.

The yellow-and- white painted 15-room building devoid of a boundary wall, which was used for the primary section, was also called the Boarding House. It did not have a boundary wall perhaps because it had nothing to loss in the hands of the thieves. That was not always the case: Backbencher students weary of studies would take advantage of this vulnerable condition of the school by putting Elfy, a super glue, in the padlocks of the classrooms. The next morning, we would shamelessly cheer after coming to know that the school locks had been Elfy-fied. Sometimes, the school would start late and at other times, when our teachers would equally feel like not teaching, the day would be called off at school.

To de-Elfy-fy the school locks, the administration would summon more peon’s from the High School to assist our sole peon, Mohammad Sharif, to open the doors. There were the ‘senior peons”— Dad Jan, Phulan, Hazoor Baksh—who we would curse at the end of the day for their masterly expertise to get the locks opened. That said, we would have to get back to school! Who would love to go to school? Not me.

A week later, Sajjad told me that his family was shifting from Chitkan, where the bazaar is located, to an official residence in Tar office, the same place for school and our home. According to the new arrangement, Sajjad’s home was at a distance of only two minutes from the school and one would require two additional minutes to walk to our house.

Our families began to visit each other while soon Sajjad and I formed a Cricket team. It was a very mobile cricket team. We would play cricket whenever we got time –mornings, afternoons and evenings. They were the days of VCRs [Video Cassette Recorders]. There were no dish antennas or cable networks then. We used to exchange Indian video cassettes in the evenings; watch them at night and discuss about them the next morning in the school. It was that time when the popular Indian movie Sajjan was released featuring Sanajy Dutt and Salman Khan. We all young people in the town started adding “Sagar” (a name used by Sanjay Dutt in the movie as his last name) or “Sajan” at the end of our names. We were like Siraj Sagar, Sajjad Sajan etc. We were not the only ones. Even a lot of people in Panjgur still use Sagar and Sajan as their last names after being inspired from the extraordinary Indian movie.

I started to know Abid after they moved to our neighborhood. His father, Dr. Syed Ali, was to become our family doctor for at least one decade. Because of their father’s profession, friends called him Doctor. I talked to Abid, who was a class fellow of my cousin Irshad and a friend of my elder brother Siddiq, for the first time when we formed a cricket team. Called Prince Cricket Club, our team was the breakaway faction of a more popular club, the Young Star Cricket Club. With my cousin Iltaf Hussain captaining the team, Abid was offered to join the team. It was the first time Abid had to play cricket. He did not know how to play the game but joined the team only to support social development in the area.

I remember how difficult a task it was in those days to bring the young people into sports clubs in an effort to prevent them from taking drugs. The best way to counter drugs in rural Balochistan has always been to promote healthy sports activities. Unfortunately, the government does not do enough to promote sports in Balochistan while, fortunately, the youth have had a history of keeping the sporting culture alive even by spending money from their own pocket money. (To Be Continued)


For background: See Amnesty International Report

AI Index: PRE01/079/2011

The Pakistan government must immediately provide accountability for the alarming number of killings and abductions in Balochistan attributed to government forces in recent months, Amnesty International said today.

Amnesty International also called on Baloch armed groups to avoid attacks that target or endanger civilians, in the face of escalating attacks on government workers and non-Baloch residents of the province.

In the last four months, at least 90 Baloch activists, teachers, journalists and lawyers have disappeared or been murdered, many in ‘kill and dump’ operations, according to information compiled by Amnesty International. Their bullet-ridden bodies, most bearing torture marks, have been recovered across Balochistan.

“Since October, every month has seen an increase in the cases of alleged disappearances and unlawful killings,” said Sam Zarifi, Amnesty International’s Asia-Pacific Director. “These atrocities are carried out with flagrant impunity. Credible investigations into these incidents – resulting in prosecutions – are absolutely necessary to establish some trust between the Baloch people and the Pakistan government.”

The victims’ relatives and Baloch groups blame the ‘kill and dump’ incidents on Pakistani security forces, particularly the Frontier Corps and intelligence agencies. Many of the victims were abducted by uniformed Frontier Corps soldiers, often accompanying men in plain clothes, in front of multiple witnesses.

Security forces deny the charges, claiming that the deaths were a result of rivalry between Baloch militant groups.

“The human rights crisis in Balochistan has largely been ignored, even inside Pakistan, but thousands of people are not only suffering from extreme deprivation but discrimination, insecurity and human rights abuses on a massive scale,” said Sam Zarifi. “Human rights abuses attributed to the security agencies have created a climate of fear for the families of the disappeared. They are terrified to speak out in fear that security agents will kill their loved ones or abduct other family members in reprisal.”

Armed Baloch groups have also been implicated in a surge in targeted killings of non-Baloch civilians and government employees, including teachers at government education institutions. Hundreds of teachers have fled the province as a result of these killings, bringing the education system to breaking point.

Baloch armed groups have claimed responsibility for a series of bombings on gas infrastructure causing a desperate shortage of fuel for cooking and heating throughout the province during the coldest period of the year. Sectarian targeted killings have also increased, and Balochistan’s Hazara Shi’a community claims that Taleban and Sunni extremists have murdered hundreds of their members since 2004.

“Baloch armed groups must also avoid endangering civilians,” said Sam Zarifi. “The apparent targeting of civilians, teachers and government officials by Baloch groups, has forced many of them to flee the province, which only worsens conditions for the already poorly-served Baloch people.”

In November 2009, the Pakistan Government attempted to address long-running Baloch grievances about economic and political disenfranchisement and human rights abuses with a package of laws called the Aghaz Huqooq-i-Balochistan (“the Beginning of Rights of Balochistan”). However, according to a recent report in the Dawn newspaper, only a quarter of the proposed measures have been implemented thus far.

Amnesty International calls on the Pakistan government to:

• Investigate all alleged human rights abuses, including all “disappearances” recorded by the judicial Commission of Inquiry for Missing Persons;

• Bring all perpetrators of abuses to justice, whether they belong to security forces or non-state armed groups; and

• Ensure that all individuals brought to justice receive a fair trial and are not subjected to torture or other abuse in detention.

“Pakistan’s foreign allies should ensure military assistance is not linked to human rights abuses in Balochistan,” said Sam Zarifi. “As Pakistan’s most significant international allies, Amnesty International calls on the United States and China to ensure their support for security forces in Balochistan does not assist human rights abusers.”


Balochistan has a long history of civil and armed unrest since the creation of Pakistan in 1947, with ethnic Baloch groups advocating greater autonomy within the state or complete separation.

Balochistan holds the largest single source of domestic energy reserves in Pakistan, but Baloch groups argue these resources disproportionately benefit other provinces and ethnic communities.

The Baloch people remain one of the poorest communities within Pakistan with some of the lowest literacy and employment rates and life expectancies.

Notes to editors

A breakdown of victims of reported disappearances and alleged extrajudicial and unlawful killings in Balochistan is available here.